GS Notes

5. Environment Notes 04

20 min read

Elaborate Notes

SPECIES

  • Introduced Species

    • Definition and Context: An introduced (or non-native, exotic, alien) species is an organism that is not indigenous to a given region or ecosystem. Its presence is a direct or indirect result of human activity. The introduction can be intentional, for purposes like agriculture (e.g., wheat in the Americas), horticulture (e.g., ornamental plants), or biological control, or it can be accidental, such as through ballast water of ships (e.g., Zebra mussel in the Great Lakes of North America) or contaminants in traded goods.
    • Historical Perspective: The process of species introduction has been a feature of human migration and trade for millennia. The “Columbian Exchange” following Christopher Columbus’s voyages in 1492 is a prime example, which saw the transfer of plants, animals, and diseases between the Old World (Europe, Asia, Africa) and the New World (the Americas).
    • Impact Spectrum: The impact of introduced species is not uniformly negative. Many form the backbone of modern agriculture and forestry. For instance, potatoes and maize, native to the Americas, are now staple foods globally. The European honey bee (Apis mellifera), as mentioned, was deliberately introduced worldwide for honey production and has become a crucial pollinator for countless agricultural crops, thereby providing a significant ecosystem service. However, a benign introduction can turn problematic if environmental conditions change.
    • Ecological Principle: The success of an introduced species often depends on the concept of the “vacant niche,” where the species can establish itself without directly competing with native species, or if it possesses traits that allow it to exploit resources more efficiently.

  • Invasive Species

    • Definition: An invasive alien species (IAS) is a subset of introduced species that proliferates, spreads, and causes harm to the environment, economy, or human health. The key distinction is the negative impact.
    • Mechanism of Harm: Invasive species disrupt ecosystems by:
      1. Competition: They outcompete native species for resources like food, water, light, and space. For example, Lantana camara, introduced as an ornamental plant by the British in India in the early 19th century, now covers vast tracts of land, suppressing the growth of native flora.
      2. Predation: An introduced predator can decimate native prey populations that have not evolved defenses against it. The brown tree snake (Boiga irregularis), accidentally introduced to Guam after World War II, led to the extinction of most of the island’s native bird species.
      3. Habitat Alteration: They can change the physical and chemical properties of an ecosystem. The water hyacinth (Eichhornia crassipes), for instance, forms dense mats on water surfaces, blocking sunlight, reducing dissolved oxygen, and altering aquatic habitats.
      4. Lack of Natural Predators: In their new environment, invasive species often lack the natural predators, parasites, and diseases that controlled their populations in their native range, allowing for explosive growth. This concept was central to Charles Elton’s seminal work, “The Ecology of Invasions by Animals and Plants” (1958), which laid the foundation for invasion ecology.
    • Economic Impact: The Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) estimates that invasive species cause global economic losses in the hundreds of billions of dollars annually, affecting agriculture, forestry, and fisheries.

  • Cosmopolitan Species

    • Definition and Distribution: A species with a cosmopolitan distribution is found across most of the world in appropriate habitats. This wide range is possible because the species is either a generalist, capable of tolerating a wide range of environmental conditions, or its specific habitat is globally widespread.
    • Examples:
      • Terrestrial: The Peregrine Falcon (Falco peregrinus) is found on every continent except Antarctica. Humans (Homo sapiens) are the ultimate cosmopolitan species.
      • Marine: The Orca (killer whale, Orcinus orca) is found in all the world’s oceans, from the Arctic to the Antarctic. The uniformity and interconnectedness of marine environments facilitate such widespread distribution. Many phytoplankton and zooplankton species are also cosmopolitan.
    • Ecological Significance: The study of cosmopolitan species helps in understanding the principles of biogeography, dispersal mechanisms, and the adaptive traits that allow organisms to thrive in diverse environments.

  • Keystone Species

    • Conceptual Origin: The concept was coined by ecologist Robert T. Paine in his 1969 paper, “A Note on Trophic Complexity and Community Stability.” His research on the intertidal zones of Washington’s coast demonstrated that removing the starfish Pisaster ochraceus caused a drastic decline in biodiversity, as its prey, the mussel Mytilus californianus, monopolized the space and crowded out other species.
    • Characteristics and Role: A keystone species has a disproportionately large effect on its ecosystem relative to its abundance. Their role is not based on numbers but on their critical functional relationships.
      1. Top Predators: They can control the populations of lower trophic level species, preventing any single species from becoming dominant (e.g., the sea otter, Enhydra lutris, preys on sea urchins, which would otherwise overgraze and destroy kelp forests).
      2. Ecosystem Engineers: Some keystone species create or significantly modify habitats. Beavers, by building dams, create wetlands that support a wide array of other species.
      3. Mutualists: Key pollinators or seed dispersers can be keystone species. For example, in the tropics, certain fig wasps are essential for the pollination of fig trees, which in turn provide a crucial food source for numerous birds and mammals.
    • Conservation Implications: The irreplaceability of keystone species makes them a high priority for conservation. Protecting a keystone species can lead to the protection of the entire ecosystem, a concept known as the “umbrella effect.” Their identification, however, is challenging and often occurs retrospectively after their removal has caused an ecosystem to collapse.

PRODUCTIVITY OF THE ECOSYSTEM

  • Core Concept: Ecosystem productivity is the rate at which biomass (biological material derived from living, or recently living organisms) is generated in an ecosystem. It is a fundamental measure of energy flow, typically expressed in units of mass per unit area per unit time (e.g., grams/m²/year) or energy per unit area per unit time (e.g., kilocalories/m²/year).

  • Primary Productivity

    • Definition: It is the synthesis of organic compounds from atmospheric or aqueous carbon dioxide, principally through photosynthesis by primary producers (autotrophs) like plants, algae, and cyanobacteria. A small fraction comes from chemosynthesis by certain bacteria in environments devoid of light.
    • Gross Primary Productivity (GPP): This is the total rate of energy capture or biomass creation by producers. It represents the total amount of photosynthesis. A significant portion of this energy is used by the producers themselves for their metabolic processes (cellular respiration, R). The equation is: GPP = NPP + R.
    • Net Primary Productivity (NPP): This is the rate of biomass accumulation by producers after subtracting the energy lost to respiration. NPP represents the energy that is actually available to the consumers (herbivores) in the ecosystem. It is the most common measure used to compare the productivity of different ecosystems.
    • Factors Influencing Primary Productivity: Key limiting factors include sunlight, temperature, water availability, and nutrient concentrations (especially nitrogen and phosphorus). This explains the high productivity of tropical rainforests (high light, water, temperature) and estuaries (high nutrient influx) and the low productivity of deserts (low water) and polar regions (low temperature and light).

  • Secondary Productivity

    • Definition: This refers to the rate of biomass generation by heterotrophs (consumers and decomposers). It is the energy that is assimilated by consumers from their food.
    • Process: When a herbivore consumes a plant, only a fraction of the energy from the NPP is converted into the herbivore’s own biomass. The rest is lost to respiration, metabolic activities, or remains unconsumed or undigested. This process continues up the food chain, with energy transfer efficiency typically being around 10% from one trophic level to the next, a concept known as the “Ten percent law” proposed by Raymond Lindeman in 1942.
    • Global Patterns: The distribution of global productivity shows a clear pattern. Terrestrial productivity is highest near the equator in tropical zones and decreases towards the poles. Marine productivity is highest in coastal zones, estuaries, and upwelling areas where nutrients are abundant, and lowest in the open ocean, which is often referred to as a “marine desert.”

BIOGEOCHEMICAL CYCLE

  • Fundamental Principle: The concept, central to the work of Vladimir Vernadsky (1926) who developed the theory of the biosphere, describes the pathway by which a chemical substance moves through both the biotic (biosphere) and abiotic (lithosphere, atmosphere, hydrosphere) components of Earth. These cycles are essential for life as they recycle finite nutrients.

  • Nutrient Categories:

    • Macronutrients: Required in large amounts for building organic molecules and cellular structures. The summary lists Nitrogen (N), Phosphorus (P), Potassium (K), Calcium (Ca), Magnesium (Mg), and Sulfur (S). Carbon (C), Hydrogen (H), and Oxygen (O) are also primary macronutrients.
    • Micronutrients (Trace Elements): Required in very small quantities, often acting as co-factors for enzymes (e.g., Iron, Manganese, Zinc).

  • Water (Hydrological) Cycle

    • Process: The cycle involves evaporation (from water bodies) and transpiration (from plants), which move water into the atmosphere. This water vapor condenses to form clouds and returns to the Earth’s surface as precipitation (rain, snow). The water then moves through runoff into rivers and oceans or infiltrates the ground to become groundwater, completing the cycle.
    • Ecological Role:
      1. Solvent and Transport Medium: Water is the universal solvent, facilitating the uptake and transport of nutrients by plants and the movement of chemicals within organisms and ecosystems.
      2. Constituent of Life: It is the primary component of living cells, comprising about 50% of hydrogen in lifeforms as noted.
      3. Energy Driver: The phase changes of water (evaporation, condensation) involve massive energy transfers, driving weather patterns and global climate. As stated, it consumes about 15% of incoming solar energy, making it a dominant force in Earth’s energy budget.

  • Phosphorus Cycle

    • Type: This is a sedimentary cycle, meaning its main reservoir is in the Earth’s crust (lithosphere) rather than the atmosphere. This makes the cycle significantly slower than gaseous cycles like nitrogen or carbon.
    • Process Breakdown:
      1. Reservoir: The primary reservoir is phosphate rocks, particularly those containing apatite minerals [Ca₅(PO₄)₃(F,Cl,OH)].
      2. Weathering: Geological uplift exposes these rocks to weathering processes (e.g., erosion by rain), which slowly release phosphate ions (PO₄³⁻) into soil and water.
      3. Uptake (Assimilation): Plants absorb dissolved inorganic phosphate from the soil and incorporate it into organic molecules like ATP, DNA, and RNA.
      4. Trophic Transfer: Animals obtain phosphorus by consuming plants or other animals.
      5. Decomposition (Mineralization): When organisms die and decompose, or excrete waste, bacteria and fungi break down the organic matter, returning inorganic phosphate to the soil and water, making it available for plants again.
      6. Loss to Sediments: A portion of the phosphorus in aquatic systems gets incorporated into sediments on the ocean floor. Over geological time scales, this sediment can be compressed into rock and eventually be uplifted to re-enter the cycle.
    • Human Impact: Human activities, particularly the use of phosphate-rich fertilizers in agriculture and detergents, have drastically altered the phosphorus cycle. Runoff from farms and urban areas leads to an excess of phosphorus in water bodies, causing cultural eutrophication—algal blooms that deplete oxygen and create “dead zones.”

Prelims Pointers

  • Introduced Species: A species present in a region due to human activity (intentional or accidental). Not always harmful. Example: Honey bees in new regions.
  • Invasive Alien Species (IAS): A non-native species that spreads and causes ecological or economic harm. Example: Lantana camara, Water Hyacinth (Eichhornia crassipes), Prosopis juliflora in India.
  • Cosmopolitan Species: A species found across most of the world in suitable habitats. Examples: Orca (killer whale), Peregrine Falcon, Humans.
  • Keystone Species: A species with a disproportionately large effect on its ecosystem relative to its abundance. Their removal can cause ecosystem collapse. Example: Sea otter, Starfish (Pisaster ochraceus), Beaver.
  • Productivity: The rate of biomass generation in an ecosystem.
  • Primary Productivity: Rate of biomass production by autotrophs (plants).
  • Gross Primary Productivity (GPP): Total photosynthesis rate, including energy used for respiration by the producer.
  • Net Primary Productivity (NPP): GPP minus respiration (R). It is the energy available to consumers. NPP = GPP - R.
  • Secondary Productivity: Rate of biomass generation by heterotrophs (consumers).
  • Productivity Ranking (Highest to Lowest):
    1. Shallow water areas (reefs, estuaries), tropical rainforests.
    2. Temperate forests, grasslands, agricultural lands.
    3. Deserts, polar areas, deep oceans.
  • Absolute Productivity (Descending Order):
    1. Forests (64.5 billion tonnes/year)
    2. Grasslands (15 billion tonnes/year)
    3. Continental Shelf (9.3 billion tonnes/year)
    4. Cultivated Land (9.1 billion tonnes/year)
  • Productivity (per m² per year):
    • Reefs and estuaries: 2000 g
    • Forest: 1300 g
    • Freshwater: 1250 g
    • Cultivated land: 650 g
    • Grassland: 600 g
    • Desert: 3 g
  • Biogeochemical Cycles: Movement of chemical elements through biotic and abiotic components of Earth.
  • Macronutrients: N, P, K, Ca, Mg, S, C, H, O.
  • Micronutrients (Trace Elements): Co, Zn, Mn, Fe.
  • Elemental Abundance in Lifeforms (Biosphere):
    1. Hydrogen: ~50%
    2. Carbon: ~25%
    3. Oxygen: ~24.8%
    4. Nitrogen: ~0.27%
  • Phosphorus Cycle: A sedimentary cycle. The main reservoir is in rocks (apatite). It is a slow cycle with no major atmospheric component.

Mains Insights

  • Invasive Alien Species: A Threat to Biodiversity and Economy (GS-III)

    • Cause-Effect Analysis:
      • Cause: Globalisation, increased trade and travel, introduction for agriculture/horticulture, lack of stringent quarantine laws.
      • Ecological Effect: Loss of native biodiversity, disruption of food webs, habitat degradation, homogenization of flora and fauna. This directly contradicts the goals of the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD), particularly Aichi Target 9.
      • Economic Effect: Massive losses in agriculture (e.g., fall armyworm in maize crops), fisheries (e.g., water hyacinth choking waterways), and forestry. High costs associated with control and eradication measures.
    • Governance and Policy Challenges: India lacks a standalone, comprehensive law to deal with invasive species. Management is fragmented across ministries (Environment, Agriculture, Health). There is a need for a robust early detection and rapid response system.
    • Way Forward: Strengthening quarantine facilities, using GIS and remote sensing for monitoring, promoting research on biological control methods, and creating public awareness are crucial steps.

  • Keystone Species and Conservation Strategy (GS-III)

    • Analytical Perspective: The concept of keystone species offers a strategic approach to conservation. Instead of trying to save every species individually (which is impractical), focusing conservation efforts on keystone species can have a cascading positive effect, preserving the entire ecosystem structure and function. This is a cost-effective “umbrella” strategy.
    • Debate: Identifying a keystone species is scientifically challenging and can be context-dependent. A species that is keystone in one ecosystem may not be so in another. Over-emphasis on a single species might lead to the neglect of other important ecological interactions. Therefore, a holistic, ecosystem-based approach is often advocated alongside species-specific programs like ‘Project Tiger’ (which can be argued as a keystone/umbrella species project).

  • Ecosystem Productivity, Climate Change, and Food Security (GS-I & GS-III)

    • Interlinkage: Climate change (rising temperatures, altered precipitation patterns, increased frequency of extreme events) directly impacts Net Primary Productivity (NPP). While some regions might see a temporary increase in NPP due to CO₂ fertilization, many key agricultural and forest regions are projected to experience a decline.
    • Consequences:
      • Food Security: Declining NPP in agricultural lands threatens crop yields and global food security.
      • Carbon Sequestration: Reduced forest productivity weakens the capacity of terrestrial ecosystems to act as carbon sinks, potentially creating a positive feedback loop that accelerates climate change.
      • Livelihoods: This impacts livelihoods dependent on agriculture, forestry, and fisheries, particularly in developing nations.
    • Policy Implication: Climate-resilient agriculture, afforestation programs focused on native species, and protecting high-productivity ecosystems like wetlands and mangroves are critical policy interventions.

  • Anthropogenic Disruption of Biogeochemical Cycles (GS-III)

    • Cause: Industrial processes, fossil fuel combustion, modern agriculture (fertilizer use), and deforestation have fundamentally altered the natural balance of cycles like Carbon, Nitrogen, and Phosphorus.
    • Phosphorus Cycle Disruption: Unlike the carbon or nitrogen cycles, which have atmospheric regulation, the phosphorus cycle is slow and easily overwhelmed. The massive influx of phosphorus from fertilizers and sewage into water bodies causes eutrophication, leading to harmful algal blooms, oxygen depletion (hypoxia), fish kills, and loss of aquatic biodiversity. This poses a significant threat to water quality and freshwater ecosystems.
    • The Phosphorus Paradox: While we are causing phosphorus pollution in our waters, we are also facing a potential shortage of high-grade phosphate rock, a finite resource essential for global food production. This presents a dual challenge of managing excess and ensuring future supply. This calls for a circular economy approach to nutrient management, including recycling phosphorus from wastewater and organic waste.

Previous Year Questions

Prelims

  1. Which one of the following is an artificial ecosystem? (UPSC CSE 2023) (a) Rice field (b) Forest (c) Grassland (d) Lake Answer: (a) A rice field is a man-made, managed ecosystem with low species diversity and external energy inputs, making it artificial. Forests, grasslands, and lakes are natural ecosystems.

  2. Which of the following are detritivores? (UPSC CSE 2021)

    1. Earthworms
    2. Jellyfish
    3. Millipedes
    4. Seahorses
    5. Woodlice Select the correct answer using the code given below. (a) 1, 2 and 4 only (b) 2, 3, 4 and 5 only (c) 1, 3 and 5 only (d) 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 Answer: (c) Detritivores feed on dead organic material (detritus). Earthworms, millipedes, and woodlice are classic examples of detritivores. Jellyfish are predators, and seahorses are predators.

  3. In the context of an ecosystem, which one of the following is a primary consumer? (UPSC CSE 2021 - Question Paraphrased for Relevance) (a) Tiger (b) Earthworm (c) Deer (d) Mushroom Answer: (c) Primary consumers are herbivores that feed on producers (plants). A deer fits this description. A tiger is a carnivore (secondary/tertiary consumer), an earthworm is a detritivore, and a mushroom is a decomposer.

  4. Why is there a great concern about the ‘microbeads’ that are released into the environment? (UPSC CSE 2019) (a) They are considered harmful to marine ecosystems. (b) They are considered to cause skin cancer in children. (c) They are small enough to be absorbed by crop plants in irrigated fields. (d) They are often found to be used as food adulterants. Answer: (a) Microbeads are a type of microplastic that pollutes water bodies. They are ingested by marine organisms, causing physical harm and introducing toxins into the food chain, thus posing a significant threat to marine ecosystems.

  5. Consider the following statements: (UPSC CSE 2019)

    1. Some species of turtles are herbivores.
    2. Some species of fish are herbivores.
    3. Some species of marine mammals are herbivores.
    4. Some species of snakes are viviparous. Which of the statements given above are correct? (a) 1 and 3 only (b) 2, 3 and 4 only (c) 2 and 4 only (d) 1, 2, 3 and 4 Answer: (d) All statements are correct. Green sea turtles are herbivores. Species like parrotfish are herbivores. Manatees and Dugongs are herbivorous marine mammals. Many snakes, like boa constrictors, give live birth (viviparous). This question tests knowledge of species’ characteristics and roles within ecosystems.

Mains

  1. What are the causes and effects of degradation of coral reefs? Suggest measures to protect them. (UPSC CSE 2023 - Paraphrased for Relevance to Ecosystems) Answer Outline:

    • Introduction: Define coral reefs as high-productivity ecosystems, often called ‘rainforests of the sea’, highlighting their keystone role in marine biodiversity.
    • Causes of Degradation:
      • Climate Change: Rising sea surface temperatures causing coral bleaching, ocean acidification hindering skeleton formation.
      • Pollution: Nutrient runoff (eutrophication), sedimentation from coastal development, plastic pollution.
      • Destructive Practices: Overfishing, bottom trawling, dynamite fishing.
      • Invasive Species: e.g., Crown-of-thorns starfish.
    • Effects of Degradation:
      • Ecological: Loss of biodiversity, collapse of reef food webs, reduced coastal protection from storms.
      • Economic: Decline in fisheries, loss of tourism revenue, impact on livelihoods of coastal communities.
    • Protective Measures:
      • Global: Mitigating climate change by adhering to Paris Agreement targets.
      • National/Local: Establishing Marine Protected Areas (MPAs), regulating coastal development, improving waste management to reduce pollution, promoting sustainable tourism, and research into coral restoration techniques.

  2. Discuss the causes of depletion of mangroves and explain their importance in maintaining coastal ecology. (UPSC CSE 2019) Answer Outline:

    • Introduction: Define mangroves as unique, high-productivity coastal ecosystems found in intertidal zones.
    • Importance in Coastal Ecology:
      • Biodiversity Hotspot: Serve as nurseries for fish and crustaceans.
      • Coastal Protection: Act as a natural barrier against tsunamis, storm surges, and coastal erosion.
      • Carbon Sequestration: Mangrove soils are highly effective carbon sinks (“blue carbon”).
      • Water Filtration: Trap sediments and pollutants, maintaining water quality.
    • Causes of Depletion:
      • Anthropogenic: Aquaculture (shrimp farming), urbanization, coastal development (ports, industries), pollution from industrial effluents and plastics.
      • Natural/Climate-related: Sea-level rise, increased salinity, extreme weather events.
    • Conclusion: Emphasize the need for integrated coastal zone management (ICZM), community participation, and afforestation with mangrove species to conserve these vital ecosystems.

  3. What is the significance of the water cycle for life on Earth? Discuss the impact of human activities on the hydrological cycle. (Model Question based on Syllabus) Answer Outline:

    • Introduction: Briefly explain the hydrological cycle as the continuous movement of water on, above, and below the surface of the Earth.
    • Significance for Life:
      • Biological: Essential for all life forms; acts as a universal solvent for nutrient transport.
      • Climatic: Drives weather patterns and moderates global temperatures through heat transfer.
      • Geological: Shapes landscapes through erosion and deposition.
      • Ecosystem Support: Sustains ecosystems from wetlands to rainforests.
    • Impact of Human Activities:
      • Over-extraction: Depletion of groundwater for agriculture and industry.
      • Land Use Change: Deforestation reduces transpiration and increases surface runoff, leading to floods and soil erosion. Urbanization with impermeable surfaces prevents groundwater recharge.
      • Pollution: Industrial and agricultural runoff contaminates water bodies.
      • Climate Change: Global warming intensifies the cycle, leading to more extreme events like droughts and floods.
    • Conclusion: Stress the need for sustainable water management practices like rainwater harvesting, efficient irrigation, and pollution control to mitigate adverse impacts.

  4. How do invasive alien species threaten the biodiversity of an ecosystem? Citing Indian examples, discuss the challenges and strategies for their management. (Model Question based on Syllabus) Answer Outline:

    • Introduction: Define Invasive Alien Species (IAS) as non-native organisms that cause ecological and economic harm.
    • Threats to Biodiversity:
      • Competition: Outcompeting native species for resources (e.g., Lantana camara).
      • Predation: Preying on native species lacking defenses.
      • Habitat Alteration: Changing ecosystem structure (e.g., Eichhornia crassipes blocking sunlight in water bodies).
      • Introduction of Diseases: Carrying pathogens harmful to native species.
    • Indian Examples: Prosopis juliflora in arid regions, Lantana camara in forests, Fall Armyworm in agriculture.
    • Challenges in Management: Lack of a unified legal framework, inadequate early detection systems, high cost of control, and lack of public awareness.
    • Management Strategies:
      • Prevention: Strict quarantine and ballast water management.
      • Control/Eradication: Mechanical, chemical, and biological control methods.
      • Policy: Enacting a dedicated national law on IAS, strengthening the National Biodiversity Authority (NBA).
    • Conclusion: A multi-pronged strategy involving prevention, early detection, and rapid response is essential to manage the IAS threat.

  5. Explain the concept of ecosystem productivity. Why do tropical rainforests and estuaries exhibit high productivity, while deep oceans and deserts show low productivity? (Model Question based on Syllabus) Answer Outline:

    • Introduction: Define ecosystem productivity as the rate of biomass generation. Differentiate between Gross Primary Productivity (GPP) and Net Primary Productivity (NPP), explaining that NPP is the energy available for the food web.
    • Reasons for High Productivity in Tropical Rainforests:
      • High year-round solar insolation.
      • Abundant rainfall and high humidity.
      • Warm temperatures optimal for photosynthesis.
      • High biodiversity and rapid nutrient cycling.
    • Reasons for High Productivity in Estuaries:
      • High nutrient influx from both freshwater rivers and the ocean.
      • Shallow water depth allows sunlight penetration to the bottom, supporting benthic producers.
      • Tidal action circulates nutrients.
    • Reasons for Low Productivity in Deep Oceans:
      • Light Limitation: Sunlight does not penetrate the aphotic zone.
      • Nutrient Limitation: Nutrients sink to the deep ocean floor and are not readily available in the sunlit photic zone (except in upwelling areas).
    • Reasons for Low Productivity in Deserts:
      • Water Limitation: Severe lack of water is the primary limiting factor for plant growth.
      • Extreme temperatures.
    • Conclusion: Conclude that ecosystem productivity is governed by the availability of key limiting factors—sunlight, water, and nutrients—which explains the vast differences observed across global biomes.

Graph View