GS Notes

19. Science and Technology Notes 12

22 min read

Elaborate Notes

Blockchain and its Core Concepts

Blockchain technology is a form of Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT) that functions as a decentralized, distributed, and often public, digital ledger. Its creation is most famously attributed to a pseudonymous person or group known as Satoshi Nakamoto, who described it in the 2008 whitepaper, “Bitcoin: A Peer-to-Peer Electronic Cash System,” as the foundational technology for the cryptocurrency Bitcoin. However, the conceptual underpinnings trace back to the work of cryptographers Stuart Haber and W. Scott Stornetta in 1991, who developed a system for time-stamping digital documents to ensure they were not backdated or tampered with.

  • Decentralized Digital Ledger: Unlike a traditional central database (e.g., a bank’s ledger) controlled by a single entity, a blockchain is distributed across numerous computers (nodes) in a network. Each node holds a complete copy of the ledger. This decentralization eliminates the need for a central intermediary or trusted third party (like a bank or government) to validate transactions, making the system ‘trustless’.
  • Chain of Blocks: Data is recorded in ‘blocks’. Each block contains a batch of transactions, a timestamp, and a reference to the previous block. This reference is a cryptographic hash of the preceding block, which creates a chronological and immutable chain. Any attempt to alter a block would change its hash, which would consequently break the link to all subsequent blocks, making the tampering immediately evident to all participants in the network.
  • Immutability and Transparency: Once a block is added to the chain, it is extremely difficult to alter or remove. This is because changing a block requires re-calculating the hashes of all subsequent blocks and gaining consensus from the majority of the network, a computationally infeasible task. Most public blockchains are transparent, meaning anyone can view the transactions on the ledger, though the identities of the participants are typically pseudonymous (represented by addresses).

Security Mechanisms in Blockchain

Blockchain’s robustness is derived from a combination of three key security layers:

  1. Cryptographic Hashing: This is a fundamental security feature. A hash function is a mathematical algorithm that takes an input of any size and produces a fixed-size string of characters, known as a ‘hash’ or ‘digest’. For example, Bitcoin uses the SHA-256 (Secure Hash Algorithm 256-bit). Key properties of cryptographic hashes are:

    • Deterministic: The same input will always produce the same output.
    • One-way: It is computationally infeasible to reverse the process and find the original input from the hash.
    • Collision Resistant: It is extremely difficult to find two different inputs that produce the same hash. Each block’s header contains the hash of the previous block’s header, thus creating a secure chain.

  2. Consensus Mechanisms (Proof-of-Work): To add a new block to the chain, network participants must agree on its validity. This agreement is achieved through a consensus mechanism.

    • Proof-of-Work (PoW): Introduced by Bitcoin, PoW is a mechanism that requires participants, known as ‘miners’, to solve a complex computational puzzle. This process, called mining, involves expending significant computational power and energy. The first miner to solve the puzzle gets to create the next block and is rewarded with cryptocurrency. As described by Adam Back in his 1997 invention of Hashcash, this “work” makes it prohibitively expensive for a malicious actor to create fraudulent blocks and take over the network. The difficulty of the puzzle adjusts over time to ensure a consistent rate of block creation.

  3. Decentralized Ledger: The distributed nature of the ledger itself is a security feature. Since every node in the network holds a copy of the blockchain, an attacker would need to compromise more than 50% of the network’s nodes simultaneously (a “51% attack”) to alter the ledger successfully. On large, public blockchains like Bitcoin, this is considered practically impossible due to the sheer number of nodes and the immense computational power required.

Applications of Blockchain Technology

The properties of immutability, transparency, and decentralization make blockchain applicable beyond cryptocurrencies. As Don Tapscott and Alex Tapscott argued in their book “Blockchain Revolution” (2016), this technology has the potential to transform various sectors.

  • Banking and Finance: Facilitating faster, cheaper, and more secure cross-border payments by removing intermediaries. It also enables decentralized finance (DeFi) platforms for lending, borrowing, and trading without traditional financial institutions.
  • Supply Chain Management: Enhancing transparency and traceability of goods. For instance, IBM’s Food Trust uses blockchain to allow participants in the food supply chain (farmers, processors, retailers) to track food items from farm to store, improving food safety and reducing fraud.
  • Governance and Public Services:
    • Land Title Registration: In India, states like Telangana and Andhra Pradesh have piloted blockchain-based land record systems to prevent fraud, reduce disputes, and ensure tamper-proof ownership records.
    • Identity Management: Creating secure and self-sovereign digital identities that give individuals control over their personal data.
    • E-voting: Potentially creating secure and transparent voting systems, though significant technical and security challenges remain.
  • Intellectual Property (IP) Protection: Creating an immutable record of the creation and ownership of IP, such as patents, copyrights, and trademarks, thereby helping to prevent infringement.
  • Healthcare: Securing patient medical records, ensuring data integrity and interoperability while giving patients control over who can access their health information.

Challenges of Blockchain Technology

  • Scalability: Public blockchains like Bitcoin can process only a limited number of transactions per second (TPS) compared to traditional systems like VISA (which can handle thousands). This is often referred to as the “blockchain trilemma,” a concept popularized by Vitalik Buterin (co-founder of Ethereum), which posits that a blockchain can only optimize for two of the following three properties: decentralization, security, and scalability.
  • Interoperability: Many blockchains operate in silos and cannot easily communicate or share data with each other, limiting their utility.
  • Energy Consumption: The PoW mechanism is notoriously energy-intensive. According to the Cambridge Bitcoin Electricity Consumption Index, Bitcoin’s annual energy consumption is comparable to that of entire countries. This has led to the development of more energy-efficient alternatives like Proof of Stake.
  • Lack of Regulation and Skills: The regulatory landscape for blockchain and crypto-assets is still evolving globally, creating uncertainty. There is also a significant shortage of developers and professionals skilled in blockchain technology.

Cryptocurrencies

A cryptocurrency is a digital or virtual asset designed to work as a medium of exchange that uses strong cryptography to secure financial transactions, control the creation of additional units, and verify the transfer of assets.

  • Key Examples:

    • Bitcoin (BTC): The first and most well-known cryptocurrency, created in 2009.
    • Ether (ETH): The native cryptocurrency of the Ethereum platform, which was launched in 2015. Ethereum introduced the concept of smart contracts—self-executing contracts with the terms of the agreement directly written into code—which greatly expanded the potential applications of blockchain.

  • Benefits:

    • Counterfeit-Resistant: Due to the cryptographic and decentralized nature of the underlying blockchain.
    • User Autonomy and Privacy: Users have more control over their funds without reliance on traditional banks. Transactions are pseudonymous.
    • Lower Transaction Costs: Especially for international transfers, as it bypasses multiple intermediaries.

  • Issues and Concerns:

    • Illicit Activities: Anonymity and pseudonymity have made cryptocurrencies a preferred medium for illegal activities, including terror financing, money laundering, and transactions on the dark web.
    • High Volatility: The value of cryptocurrencies can fluctuate dramatically in short periods, making them a risky investment and an unstable store of value. This volatility poses a risk to macroeconomic and financial stability.
    • Lack of Consumer Protection: There is no central authority for dispute resolution or to recover lost funds (e.g., if a user loses their private keys).
    • Regulatory Uncertainty: Governments worldwide are grappling with how to regulate cryptocurrencies. The Government of India and the RBI have consistently cautioned against the risks associated with them. The Union Budget 2022-23 introduced a 30% tax on income from the transfer of any virtual digital asset, signaling a move towards regulation rather than an outright ban.

Proof of Stake (PoS)

Proof of Stake is a consensus mechanism that emerged as an alternative to the energy-intensive PoW.

  • Mechanism: In PoS, instead of miners competing to solve a puzzle, participants known as ‘validators’ are chosen to create new blocks based on the number of coins they hold and are willing to ‘stake’ as collateral. Validators lock up a certain amount of their cryptocurrency. If they validate a fraudulent transaction, they lose their stake (a process called ‘slashing’). This economic incentive ensures they act honestly.
  • Key Example: The Ethereum blockchain successfully transitioned from PoW to PoS in an event known as “The Merge” in September 2022. This move was primarily driven by the need to reduce the network’s energy consumption by an estimated 99.95%.

Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs)

An NFT is a unique cryptographic token that represents ownership of a specific digital or physical asset and cannot be replicated. Unlike cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin, which are ‘fungible’ (one Bitcoin is interchangeable with another), each NFT is unique and non-interchangeable.

  • How it Works: NFTs are created (or ‘minted’) on a blockchain, most commonly Ethereum. The blockchain provides a public, verifiable proof of ownership and a record of the asset’s transaction history.
  • Examples of Assets: Digital art, music, videos, in-game items, virtual land, and even tweets can be represented as NFTs. A famous example is the digital artist Beeple, whose NFT collage “Everydays: The First 5000 Days” was sold at Christie’s for $69.3 million in 2021.
  • Function: An NFT acts as a digital certificate of authenticity and ownership. While anyone can view or download the digital file associated with an NFT, only the owner of the NFT holds the official ownership rights recorded on the blockchain. The perceived value is subjective and driven by market demand, similar to physical art.

Prelims Pointers

  • Blockchain: A decentralized, distributed, and immutable digital ledger. It is a type of Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT).
  • Satoshi Nakamoto: The pseudonymous creator of Bitcoin and the author of the 2008 whitepaper that first described blockchain technology in practice.
  • Cryptographic Hashing: A one-way function that converts an input into a fixed-size string of characters. Bitcoin uses the SHA-256 algorithm.
  • Consensus Mechanism: The protocol through which nodes in a network agree on the state of the ledger.
  • Proof of Work (PoW): A consensus mechanism requiring participants (‘miners’) to solve a computational puzzle to validate transactions and create new blocks. It is energy-intensive.
  • Proof of Stake (PoS): A consensus mechanism where block creators (‘validators’) are chosen based on the number of coins they hold and stake as collateral. It is more energy-efficient than PoW.
  • Ethereum Merge: The event in September 2022 when the Ethereum blockchain transitioned from Proof of Work (PoW) to Proof of Stake (PoS).
  • Cryptocurrency: A digital or virtual currency secured by cryptography. Examples include Bitcoin (BTC) and Ether (ETH).
  • Smart Contract: A self-executing contract with the terms of the agreement directly written into code. A key feature of the Ethereum blockchain.
  • Non-Fungible Token (NFT): A unique and non-interchangeable digital token representing ownership of a specific asset on a blockchain.
  • Fungibility: The property of an asset whose individual units are essentially interchangeable. Example: A Rs. 100 note is fungible with any other Rs. 100 note. Bitcoin is fungible.
  • Non-Fungibility: The property of an asset that is unique and not interchangeable. Example: The Mona Lisa painting is non-fungible. NFTs are non-fungible.
  • India’s Crypto Tax: The Union Budget 2022-23 introduced a 30% tax on income from the transfer of Virtual Digital Assets (VDAs).

Mains Insights

1. Blockchain as a Tool for Good Governance (GS Paper II)

  • Potential for Transparency and Accountability: Blockchain’s immutable and transparent ledger can revolutionize public service delivery.
    • Cause-Effect: By creating a tamper-proof record of land ownership (e.g., projects in Telangana), blockchain can reduce litigation, curb corruption, and streamline property transfers. Similarly, in Public Distribution Systems (PDS), it can track the movement of food grains from procurement to the beneficiary, plugging leakages.
    • Challenges: Implementation requires significant digital infrastructure, digital literacy among officials and citizens, and robust legal frameworks. The cost and complexity of transitioning from legacy systems are major hurdles.

2. Cryptocurrencies: Economic Opportunity or Financial Threat? (GS Paper III)

  • Debate on Regulation: The core debate is whether to treat cryptocurrencies as a currency, a commodity, or a unique asset class.
    • Viewpoint 1 (Pro-Innovation): Proponents argue that a blanket ban would stifle innovation in a nascent technology. They advocate for a regulatory sandbox approach, allowing for experimentation while managing risks. Regulation can bring legitimacy, protect investors, and enable taxation.
    • Viewpoint 2 (Pro-Financial Stability - RBI’s Stance): The Reserve Bank of India has repeatedly warned that private cryptocurrencies pose serious threats to macroeconomic and financial stability. They undermine the central bank’s control over monetary policy and can be used for money laundering and terror financing. This viewpoint favors a Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) over private alternatives.
  • Cause-Effect Relationship: The high volatility of cryptocurrencies can lead to massive wealth erosion for retail investors. Their anonymous nature facilitates illicit capital flows, posing a challenge to national security and economic sovereignty.

3. Environmental and Ethical Dimensions of Digital Assets (GS Paper III & IV)

  • Environmental Impact (GS-III): The energy consumption of Proof-of-Work mining is a significant environmental concern.
    • Analysis: The debate is not just about energy use but the source of that energy. While some mining operations use renewable energy, many rely on fossil fuels. The shift of major blockchains like Ethereum to Proof of Stake represents a significant technological solution to this problem, demonstrating the industry’s capacity for self-correction.
  • Ethical Concerns (GS-IV): The principle of anonymity, while lauded for privacy, presents an ethical dilemma.
    • Dilemma: It pits the individual’s right to privacy against the state’s responsibility to prevent crime and maintain order. How can a balance be struck? Can technology like Zero-Knowledge Proofs offer a solution by verifying transactions without revealing underlying data? This is a key ethical and technological question for policymakers.

4. The Future of Digital Assets: NFTs and the Metaverse

  • Analysis: NFTs represent a paradigm shift in the concept of ownership in the digital realm.
    • Opportunity: They empower creators by allowing them to monetize their work directly and retain a share of future sales. They are the building blocks for the ‘Metaverse’—a persistent, shared virtual space—by enabling true ownership of virtual goods and land.
    • Bubble or Revolution?: Critics argue that the current NFT market is a speculative bubble driven by hype. The long-term value will depend on their utility beyond digital collectibles. The key challenge is to move from speculative trading to creating genuine economic value and use cases.

Previous Year Questions

Prelims

  1. With reference to “Blockchain Technology”, consider the following statements: (UPSC Prelims 2020)

    1. It is a public ledger that everyone can inspect, but which no single user controls.
    2. The structure and design of blockchain is such that all the data in it are about cryptocurrency only.
    3. Applications that depend on basic features of blockchain can be developed without anybody’s permission. Which of the statements given above is/are correct? (a) 1 only (b) 1 and 2 only (c) 2 only (d) 1 and 3 only

    Answer: (d) 1 and 3 only Explanation: Statement 1 is correct as it defines the core nature of a public blockchain. Statement 2 is incorrect because blockchain can store various types of data, not just cryptocurrency transactions (e.g., land records, supply chain data, medical records). Statement 3 is correct for public, permissionless blockchains like Ethereum, where anyone can build applications (dApps) on top of the platform.

  2. Which one of the following is not the most likely measure the Government/RBI takes to stop the slide of the Indian rupee? (UPSC Prelims 2019) (a) Curbing imports of non-essential goods and promoting exports. (b) Encouraging Indian borrowers to issue rupee-denominated Masala Bonds. (c) Easing conditions relating to external commercial borrowing. (d) Following an expansionary monetary policy.

    Answer: (d) Following an expansionary monetary policy. Explanation: This question is indirectly related. An expansionary monetary policy (like cutting interest rates) would decrease the return on Indian assets, leading to capital outflow and further depreciation of the rupee. The rise of cryptocurrencies is sometimes seen as a form of capital flight that can impact a country’s currency, making the RBI’s control over monetary policy a relevant topic.

  3. Consider the following statements: (UPSC Prelims 2022)

    1. A bill amending the Constitution requires a prior recommendation of the President of India.
    2. When a Constitution Amendment Bill is presented to the President of India, it is obligatory for the President of India to give his/her assent.
    3. A Constitution Amendment Bill must be passed by both the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha by a special majority and there is no provision for a joint sitting. Which of the statements given above are correct? (a) 1 and 2 only (b) 2 and 3 only (c) 1 and 3 only (d) 1, 2 and 3

    Answer: (b) 2 and 3 only Explanation: While not directly about blockchain, this question relates to the legislative process. Any future law to regulate or ban cryptocurrencies would have to go through parliamentary procedures. Understanding these is crucial. Statement 1 is incorrect. Statements 2 and 3 are correct descriptions of the process for a Constitution Amendment Bill.

  4. With reference to Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs), consider the following statements: (UPSC Prelims 2022)

    1. They enable the digital representation of physical assets.
    2. They are unique cryptographic tokens that exist on a blockchain.
    3. They can be traded or exchanged at equivalency and therefore can be used as a medium of commercial transactions. Which of the statements given above are correct? (a) 1 and 2 only (b) 2 and 3 only (c) 1 and 3 only (d) 1, 2 and 3

    Answer: (a) 1 and 2 only Explanation: Statement 1 is correct, as NFTs can represent ownership of physical assets like art or real estate. Statement 2 is the core definition of an NFT. Statement 3 is incorrect. NFTs are ‘non-fungible’, meaning they are not interchangeable or equivalent. They cannot be exchanged at equivalency like currency, which is fungible.

  5. With reference to the Indian economy, consider the following statements: (UPSC Prelims 2022)

    1. If the inflation is too high, Reserve Bank of India (RBI) is likely to buy government securities.
    2. If the rupee is rapidly depreciating, RBI is likely to sell dollars in the market.
    3. If interest rates in the USA or European Union were to fall, that is likely to induce RBI to buy more dollars. Which of the statements given above are correct? (a) 1 and 2 only (b) 2 and 3 only (c) 1 and 3 only (d) 1, 2 and 3

    Answer: (b) 2 and 3 only Explanation: This question relates to the macroeconomic environment in which cryptocurrencies operate. The RBI’s concerns about crypto stem from its potential to disrupt these very mechanisms of monetary control. Statement 1 is incorrect; to curb inflation, the RBI sells securities to absorb liquidity. Statements 2 and 3 are correct policy responses.

Mains

  1. What is the blockchain technology? How does it work? Discuss its potential applications in different sectors. (Hypothetical, based on common themes)

    Answer Framework:

    • Introduction: Define blockchain as a decentralized, distributed, and immutable ledger technology, mentioning its origin with Bitcoin.
    • How it Works (Body Part 1): Explain the core concepts in simple terms:
      • Blocks and Chain: Explain how transactions are bundled into blocks and linked chronologically using cryptographic hashes.
      • Decentralization: Contrast it with a centralized database. Explain the role of nodes in maintaining the ledger.
      • Consensus Mechanism: Briefly explain PoW or PoS as a method to validate transactions and secure the network.
      • Immutability: Explain why it is tamper-proof.
    • Potential Applications (Body Part 2): Discuss at least 4-5 sectors with specific examples.
      • Finance: Cross-border payments, trade finance, DeFi.
      • Governance: Land records, identity management, PDS.
      • Supply Chain: Food safety (IBM Food Trust), tracking pharmaceuticals.
      • Healthcare: Secure medical records.
      • Intellectual Property: Proving ownership and preventing plagiarism.
    • Conclusion: Summarize the transformative potential of blockchain while acknowledging challenges like scalability, energy consumption, and the need for a conducive regulatory environment.

  2. Discuss the potential of Distributed Ledger Technology (DLT) to revolutionize the banking sector. What are the challenges in its adoption by Indian banks? (Hypothetical, based on common themes)

    Answer Framework:

    • Introduction: Define DLT and state that blockchain is its most common implementation. Mention its core promise for the banking sector: enhancing efficiency, transparency, and security.
    • Potential to Revolutionize Banking (Body Part 1):
      • Cross-Border Payments: Faster and cheaper settlement by removing correspondent banks (e.g., Ripple).
      • Trade Finance: Digitizing letters of credit and bills of lading, reducing fraud and paperwork.
      • KYC (Know Your Customer): A shared, secure KYC ledger could reduce duplication and costs for banks.
      • Syndicated Loans: Streamlining communication and settlement among multiple lenders.
      • Clearing and Settlement: Near-instant settlement of securities, reducing counterparty risk.
    • Challenges in Adoption in India (Body Part 2):
      • Regulatory Uncertainty: Lack of clear guidelines from RBI and the government on DLT and associated crypto-assets.
      • Integration with Legacy Systems: Indian banks run on complex, established core banking systems. Integrating DLT is a major technological and financial challenge.
      • Interoperability: Lack of standards for different DLT platforms to communicate with each other.
      • Scalability and Performance: The current TPS of many DLTs may not be sufficient for the high volume of transactions in the Indian banking system.
      • Lack of Skilled Talent: Shortage of developers and experts in blockchain technology.
    • Conclusion: Conclude by stating that despite challenges, the potential benefits are immense. A collaborative approach involving banks, regulators (like RBI), and technology firms through sandboxes and pilot projects is the way forward.

  3. Cryptocurrencies have been a subject of intense debate in India. Critically analyse the arguments for and against their legalisation in the country. (Hypothetical, based on common themes)

    Answer Framework:

    • Introduction: Briefly introduce cryptocurrencies and the context of the global and Indian debate surrounding their status. Mention the Indian government’s move to tax them while not granting legal tender status.
    • Arguments for Legalisation and Regulation (Body Part 1):
      • Fostering Innovation: A ban would stifle innovation in the burgeoning Web3 and blockchain ecosystem.
      • Economic Opportunity: Can be a new asset class for investment; can attract foreign investment and create jobs.
      • Tax Revenue: Regulation allows the government to tax transactions and profits, as is being done now.
      • Financial Inclusion: Potential to provide financial services to the unbanked.
      • Bringing it to the Mainstream: A ban would drive the industry underground, making it harder to monitor. Regulation brings it under purview.
    • Arguments Against Legalisation (Body Part 2):
      • Financial Stability Risk: High volatility can impact investors and the broader economy.
      • Undermining Monetary Policy: Private currencies can challenge the RBI’s control over money supply and the rupee’s status.
      • Illicit Activities: Anonymity makes them a tool for money laundering, terror financing, and tax evasion.
      • Lack of Consumer Protection: No recourse for fraud or loss of funds.
      • Environmental Concerns: Energy-intensive PoW mining.
    • Critical Analysis and Way Forward (Conclusion):
      • Weigh both sides and suggest a balanced approach. Instead of an outright ban or full legalisation as currency, India can adopt a “regulate and monitor” approach, treating them as a distinct asset class.
      • Suggest measures like a robust KYC/AML framework, investor education, and promoting a CBDC as a safer alternative.

  4. How can S&T be used to strengthen the farm-to-fork supply chain for agricultural products in India? Discuss with a special focus on emerging technologies. (Related application)

    Answer Framework:

    • Introduction: Explain the concept of the farm-to-fork supply chain and its current inefficiencies in India (wastage, intermediaries, lack of transparency).
    • Role of S&T (Body):
      • Blockchain: Detail how blockchain can create a transparent and immutable record.
        • Traceability: Consumers can scan a QR code to see the product’s entire journey, ensuring authenticity and quality.
        • Fair Prices: Farmers can get better price discovery by connecting directly with buyers on a transparent platform.
        • Efficiency: Reduces paperwork and delays in logistics and payments.
      • Other Technologies: Briefly mention IoT (sensors for monitoring crop conditions and storage), AI/ML (for demand forecasting and price prediction), and Drones (for crop monitoring and pesticide spraying).
    • Conclusion: Summarize how the integration of these technologies, with blockchain as the foundational layer for trust, can create a more efficient, transparent, and profitable agricultural supply chain, benefiting both farmers and consumers.

  5. Examine the risks and opportunities associated with Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs). Is it a speculative bubble or the future of digital ownership? (Hypothetical, based on current affairs)

    Answer Framework:

    • Introduction: Define NFTs as unique digital certificates of ownership on a blockchain and highlight their recent surge in popularity and value.
    • Opportunities (Body Part 1):
      • Empowering Creators: Artists, musicians, and other creators can directly monetize their work and earn royalties on secondary sales.
      • Digital Identity & Ownership: Establishes verifiable ownership in the digital world, crucial for the Metaverse.
      • New Business Models: Enables fractional ownership of assets, ticketing for events, and unique in-game items.
      • Tokenization of Real-World Assets: Potential to represent ownership of physical assets like real estate or art, making them more liquid.
    • Risks (Body Part 2):
      • Speculative Bubble: Prices are often driven by hype and market sentiment rather than intrinsic value, leading to high volatility and risk of collapse.
      • IP and Copyright Issues: Ownership of an NFT doesn’t always automatically grant copyright to the underlying asset, leading to legal ambiguities.
      • Fraud and Scams: The market is rife with plagiarism (minting someone else’s work), phishing scams, and “rug pulls” (where developers abandon a project after raising funds).
      • Environmental Impact: Most NFTs are on PoW blockchains like Ethereum (pre-Merge), raising environmental concerns.
    • Bubble or Future? (Conclusion): Conclude with a balanced view. Acknowledge that the current market has bubble-like characteristics. However, the underlying technology of verifiable digital ownership is revolutionary and likely to persist. The future will see a shift from speculative hype towards NFTs with real-world utility and integration into mainstream applications.

Graph View